Comparison: Sinful Colors Stoned Crystal Shimmers & Dance Legend Mist Way & Illamasqua Raindrops and Pink Raindrops


Hi everyone! It was brought up on a Facebook group I’m in that the newish Sinful Colors Stoned Crystal Shimmers collection may be close to the Dance Legend Mist Way colors and Illamasqua Raindrops & Pink Raindrops. Well, I have a few of the Mist Way colors and both of the Illamasqua’s, so I thought I would do a comparison and give my thoughts on these polishes.

04-08-2017 Comp Sinful.Dance Leg.Illa -- RealPolishFanatic
Comparison: Sinful Colors Stoned Crystal Shimmers & Dance Legend Mist Way & Illamasqua Raindrops and Pink Raindrops

 

I will start with the bottle shots of the colors I compared…

04-08-2017 Sinful.Dance Leg. Illa Comp .1 -- RealPolishFanatic
Comparison: Sinful Colors Stoned Crystal Shimmers & Dance Legend Mist Way & Illamasqua Raindrops and Pink Raindrops

 

04-08-2017 Sinful.Dance Leg. Illa Comp .2 -- RealPolishFanatic
Comparison: Sinful Colors Stoned Crystal Shimmers & Dance Legend Mist Way & Illamasqua Raindrops and Pink Raindrops

 

04-08-2017 Sinful.Dance Leg. Illa Comp .3 -- RealPolishFanatic
Comparison: Sinful Colors Stoned Crystal Shimmers & Dance Legend Mist Way & Illamasqua Raindrops and Pink Raindrops

 

 

Now I will show you on my nail wheel one coat (no top coat) of each color.

Photos taken in a bright area inside, no flash…

04-08-2017.8 Sinful.Dance Leg.Illa Comp 1 COAT (1)
Comparison: Sinful Colors Stoned Crystal Shimmers & Dance Legend Mist Way & Illamasqua Raindrops and Pink Raindrops
04-08-2017.8 Sinful.Dance Leg.Illa Comp 1 COAT (2)
Comparison: Sinful Colors Stoned Crystal Shimmers & Dance Legend Mist Way & Illamasqua Raindrops and Pink Raindrops
04-08-2017.8 Sinful.Dance Leg.Illa Comp 1 COAT (3)
Comparison: Sinful Colors Stoned Crystal Shimmers & Dance Legend Mist Way & Illamasqua Raindrops and Pink Raindrops

 

And here is two coats of each color (no top coat) on my nail wheel. Photos taken in a bright area inside, no flash…

 

04-08-2017.1 Sinful.Dance Leg.Illa Comp 2 COATS.2 (1)
Comparison: Sinful Colors Stoned Crystal Shimmers & Dance Legend Mist Way & Illamasqua Raindrops and Pink Raindrops
04-08-2017.1 Sinful.Dance Leg.Illa Comp 2 COATS.2 (3)
Comparison: Sinful Colors Stoned Crystal Shimmers & Dance Legend Mist Way & Illamasqua Raindrops and Pink Raindrops
04-08-2017.1 Sinful.Dance Leg.Illa Comp 2 COATS.2 (2)
Comparison: Sinful Colors Stoned Crystal Shimmers & Dance Legend Mist Way & Illamasqua Raindrops and Pink Raindrops

 

 

And here is two coats of each color (no top coat) on my nail wheel. Photos taken inside in sun through a window…

04-08-2017.7 Sinful.Dance Leg.Illa Comp 2 COATS (1)
Comparison: Sinful Colors Stoned Crystal Shimmers & Dance Legend Mist Way & Illamasqua Raindrops and Pink Raindrops
04-08-2017.7 Sinful.Dance Leg.Illa Comp 2 COATS (2)
Comparison: Sinful Colors Stoned Crystal Shimmers & Dance Legend Mist Way & Illamasqua Raindrops and Pink Raindrops
04-08-2017.7 Sinful.Dance Leg.Illa Comp 2 COATS (4)
Comparison: Sinful Colors Stoned Crystal Shimmers & Dance Legend Mist Way & Illamasqua Raindrops and Pink Raindrops

 

 

04-08-2017.7 Sinful.Dance Leg.Illa Comp 2 COATS (3) -- RealPolishFanatic
Comparison: Sinful Colors Stoned Crystal Shimmers & Dance Legend Mist Way & Illamasqua Raindrops and Pink Raindrops

 

 

My thoughts: As you see, there are no true dupes here. The feel of all the polishes is the same since they all have iridescent flakies. The Dance Legends were very sheer and the flakes are not abundant. I would group Illamasqua Raindrops into that description as well.

Illamasqua Pink Raindrops is more opaque and it also has an additional shimmer in the bottle. It is actually very close to Sinful Just Deserts. It is just a bit more pink toned, but pretty close in real life.

The Sinful’s had the best formulas and the best flakie presence. For being the cheapest polish of the lot, if you are looking for a iridescent flakie polish, Sinful is really superior to the Dance Legend’s (which retail for $10 each) and the Illamasqua’s (which retail for $18 each) (although I will say Pink Raindrops is really very nice too).

 

 

 

Well, there we have it!
Thanks so much for stopping by!

The polish in this post is from my own collection and was purchased by me.
©2017 RealPolishFanatic / All Rights Reserved


If you like what you see,
please take a second to push the
“Like” button at the bottom of the post
and follow me so you never miss an entry!

 

About Me & My Blog

My blog is a beauty based blog, specifically about Nail Polish: Nail Polish swatches, Nail Polish comparisons, Nail Polish collections, my Manicure of the Day. All content and photos are my own property and cannot be used without my express written consent.

My name is Paula and I live in California right now with my hubby of many years and Chico my “baby”. You will see him featured periodically at the end of a post (the dog, not the hubby).🙂

READ MORE

I would love to hear from you!

Happy polishing!!

♥Paula

 

 

 

 

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s